A contract is a fundamental legal instrument that governs agreement between parties. It establishes rights, obligations, and legal protections, ensuring that each party fulfil their commitments. In the realm of business and personal contracts, understanding the legal requirements for a valid contract is crucial. In Indonesia, the validity of a contract is primarily regulated by Article 1320 of the Indonesian Civil Code/KUHPerdata. Additionally, industry-specific regulations may impose further requirements, such as those for labor contracts, real estate transactions, and investment agreements. This article delves into the essential elements that make a contract legally binding under Indonesian law, ensuring your contracts are both enforceable and compliant. Additionally, various legal doctrines and principles have shaped contract law, providing a deeper understanding of its enforceability.
Essential Requirements for a Valid Contract (Article 1320 Indonesian Civil Code)
Under Article 1320 Indonesian Civil Code, a contract is considered valid if it meets the following four conditions:
1. Consent of the Parties (Kesepakatan Para Pihak)
Consent is the fundamental basis of contract formation. Both parties must voluntarily and knowingly agree to the terms of the contract. Consent must be given without coercion (dwang), fraud (bedrog), or mistake (dwaling).
2. Legal Capacity (Kecakapan Para Pihak)
The parties entering into a contract must have the legal capacity to do so. This means they must be:
- Of legal age (at least 21 years old or married, as per Article 330 Indonesian Civil Code).
- Not under guardianship (curatele), which applies to individuals deemed legally incompetent due to mental illness or excessive debt.
3. Definite Subject Matter (Suatu Hal Tertentu)
The valid contract must have a clear and specific object, which refers to the subject matter of the contract. This means:
- The object must be identifiable and specific (e.g., goods, services, or rights).
- The object must be capable of being executed (not impossible).
- The object must be lawful and not contrary to public policy or morality.
A contract lacking a clear subject matter is considered null and void (batal demi hukum).
4. Lawful Cause (Sebab yang Halal)
A valid contract must have a lawful cause, meaning its purpose should not violate the law, public order, or good morals.
Examples of unlawful contracts include:
- Contracts related to illegal activities (e.g., drug trafficking, bribery).
- Contracts that violate public order (e.g., contracts to commit crimes).
- Contracts that contradict moral values (e.g., contracts promoting unethical conduct).
If a contract is made for an unlawful purpose, it is automatically null and void (batal demi hukum).
Consequences of Non-Compliance with Article 1320 Indonesian Civil Code
If a contract fails to meet the four essential requirements, the legal consequences are as follows:
- If there is a defect in consent – The contract is voidable (dapat dibatalkan) and can be annulled by the affected party.
- If a party lacks legal capacity – The contract can be challenged and potentially annulled.
- If the contract lacks a definite subject matter – The contract is null and void (batal demi hukum).
- If the contract has an unlawful cause – The contract is null and void (batal demi hukum).
Read more: Employment in Indonesia: Types and Regulations
Key Challenges in Contract Drafting & Review
Despite these clear legal requirements, individuals and companies often face challenges in ensuring contract validity. Below are some of the most common issues:
1. Ambiguous or Unclear Terms
Many contracts lack clarity, leading to disputes over interpretation. Key terms such as scope of work, payment terms, penalties, and dispute resolution must be clearly defined.
2. Unfair or One-Sided Clauses
Some contracts contain excessively burdensome obligations on one party, violating the principle of balance (asas keseimbangan). In consumer contracts, unfair terms may be declared unenforceable under Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection.
3. Failure to Meet Legal Formalities
While many contracts are valid upon contract, certain contracts require formal documentation, such as:
- Land and property sales – Must be notarized (Article 1879 Indonesian Civil Code).
- Employment contracts – Must be in writing for contract employee whereas for permanent employee could be in oral or written contract (Law No. 13 of 2003 on Manpower).
- Marriage contracts – Must be notarized (Article 29 of the Marriage Law).
4. Failure to Consider Future Risks & Dispute Resolution
Many contracts fail to address potential risks, such as force majeure, breach of contract, or regulatory changes. A strong dispute resolution clause (e.g., arbitration or mediation) is essential to avoid costly litigation.
5. Compliance with International or Sector-Specific Regulations
Companies operating cross-border or in regulated industries (e.g., healthcare, finance) must ensure contracts comply with sector-specific laws. For example, contracts in the medical devices sector must align with BPOM and Ministry of Health regulations. Then for finance business sector should comply with OJK regulation.
6. Failure to Make a Contract Useful for Business Needs
Companies or a person somehow only considering the formalities of a contract but fail to make a contract agile for their needs. It is a must that a contract should meet your needs and implementable. Many contracts only use as formalities but the content is difficult to understand or even make your flexibility limited.
Solution: Companies or a person as a contract parties should understand their needs and business in the first place. Then understanding the laws, principles, and doctrine also an obligation to make a good contract drafting and review. You are suggested to consult with legal experts to ensure compliance in every aspect and to ensure your contracts fulfil your needs. Contact us to consult!
Legal Principles and Doctrines Related to a Valid Contract
- Consensualism Principle (Asas Konsensualisme) – This principle asserts that a contract is formed as soon as the parties reach an contract, without requiring additional formalities unless stipulated by law.
- Freedom of Contract (Asas Kebebasan Berkontrak, Article 1338 Indonesian Civil Code) – Parties are free to determine the content of their contract, provided it does not violate the law, public order, or morality.
- Pacta Sun Servanda/Legal Certainty – This doctrine states that contracts made legally must be honored and enforced. As stated in article 1338 Indonesian Civil Code “all legally formed contracts act as laws for the parties involved.
- Good Faith – The doctrine of good faith requires that all parties to a contract act honestly and fairly in their dealings. This principle is embedded in Article 1338 of the Indonesian Civil Code, which states that contracts must be performed in good faith. This doctrine ensures that parties cannot exploit ambiguities or loopholes in the contract to the detriment of the other party.
- Principle of Balance – The principle of balance in contract law ensures fairness and equality between contracting parties. This principle prevents one party from exploiting another through unfair contract terms. This principle stated in article 1339 Indonesian Civil Code that contracts must be executed in good faith and implemented in article 18 of Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection that prohibits unfair contract clauses that disproportionately benefit one party.
- Non-Discrimination – The principles of non-discrimination ensures that contracts must be entered into without bias based on gender, race, religion, or other protected categories. This principle aligns with human rights principles in business and fair contractual practices.
- Impossibility of Performance – This doctrine addresses situations where it becomes impossible to fulfill the terms of a contract due to unforeseen circumstances, such as natural disasters or changes in law. In such cases, the contract may be deemed void or subject to renegotiation. This principle ensures that parties are not unfairly penalized for circumstances beyond their control.
- Doctrine of Legal Capacity (Doktrin Kecakapan Hukum) – This doctrine emphasizes that a person must have the ability to understand and undertake legal actions responsibly.
- Incapacity Nullifies Consent (Asas Ketidakcakapan Membatalkan Kesepakatan) – A contract made by an incapacitated person may be annulled by law.
- Illegality Doctrine (Doktrin Ketidakabsahan) – If a contract’s purpose is illegal, courts will refuse to enforce it.
- Ex Turpi Causa Non Oritur Actio – A legal principle stating that no legal action arises from an illegal cause.
Read more: Why Guarantees in Loan Agreements Matter
Conclusion
A valid contract under Indonesian law must meet the four essential elements of consent, legal capacity, a definite subject matter, and a lawful cause. However, drafting and reviewing contracts present significant challenges, including ambiguous terms, unfair clauses, failure to meet legal formalities, and lack of risk management provisions.
By adhering to best practices in contract drafting and review, businesses and individuals can mitigate legal risks, ensure enforceability, and foster successful contractual relationships. Seeking legal consultation is highly recommended to navigate complex contractual obligations and safeguard interests.
Contract Drafting & Contract Review Assistance in Indonesia with Kusuma & Partners Law Firm
Our firm specializes in Contract Drafting & Contract Review, ensuring that all contracts comply with Indonesian laws and regulations. We provide strategic legal guidance, draft and review contract to mitigate risks, and safeguard our clients interests in every transaction. With extensive experience in Contract Drafting & Contract Review, we help businesses create clear, enforceable, and legally sound contracts tailored to their needs.
Our Services Included:
- Drafting & Reviewing Business Contracts – Ensuring clarity, enforceability, and compliance with Indonesian law.
- Legal Risk Assessment – identifying and mitigating potential legal risks in contracts
- Negotiation Support – Assisting in contract negotiation to protect your business interests
Partner with us for reliable, professional, and strategic legal solutions that safeguard your business from confusing of Contract Law and resolve the dispute with the best solution. Fill out the form below.
“DISCLAIMER: This content is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be treated as legal advice. For professional advice, please consult us